SCHOLEDGE INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT & DEVELOPMENT
VOL. 2, ISSUE 5 (MAY 2015) ISSN-2394-3378
www.scholedge.org; www.journal.scholedge.org; www.library.scholedge.org
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HUMAN RESOURCE ACCOUNTING: IMPLICATIONS & ADOPTION
Henry Chao
Affiliated Faculty
Universiti Sains Malaysia
Palau Pinang, MALAYSIA.
ABSTRACT
HR are really the most significant assets a firm can have on the grounds that compelling usage of physical and monetary assets rely on nature of HR. Viable Human Resource Management is imperative as individuals produce benefit though machines and capital simply upgrade the benefit making ability. Human Resource Accounting is the procedure of recognizing and measuring information about HR and conveying this data to invested individuals. Fundamentally HRA is a data framework that tells administration what changes after some time are jumping out at the HR of the association. In spite of the fact that HRA is exceptionally helpful in choice making and, after its all said and done not very many organizations are approaching to esteem this critical resource. Numerous organizations in India and abroad began reporting HRA yet later on they quit doing it. It was seen that certain issues were connected with the utilization of human asset bookkeeping framework. The present paper condenses the aftereffect of a review directed to know the impression of chiefs with respect to issue regions in creating and initiating the HRA framework.
Keywords:
HR, Human Resource Accounting, Human Resource Management, Probable issues, Decision-Making
Presentation
Human Resource Accounting will be representing individuals as a hierarchical asset. It includes measuring the expense caused by business firms and associations to enroll, select, contract, prepare and create human resources. It likewise includes measuring the financial estimation of individuals to the association. Human asset bookkeeping gives money related information with respect to the HR of the association that is of high importance not just for the administration in taking different choices additionally for the expert and the representatives. It can be valuable for the administration in ranges of enrollment, arranging, choice (Flamholtz 1971), assignment of money related assets, preservation of HR, use of HR (Gupta 1990), formation of a helpful hierarchical atmosphere, better worker executive relations and so on. For the investigator it not just gives data with respect to the inward quality of the association additionally helps in settling on choices in regards to the long haul interest in that association. This additionally influences dealing force and execution of representatives.
In spite of this significance of HRA the investigation of HR of an association has not got the consideration it merits. In India numerous associations presented the framework however
inspite of the advantages of HRA numerous associations quit reporting HRA data. BHEL was pioneer in the presentation of HRA in India and R.G. Barry Corporation in the USA yet both quit esteeming HR. It was seen that certain issues were connected with the utilization of human asset bookkeeping framework.
Survey OF LITERATURE
Human Resource Accounting data can be helpful for administrative choice making in diverse regions. Numerous examination studies were led to demonstrate this. Tomassini (1977) completed a lab study to inspect the impacts of HRA expense information in work force cutback choice connection. He reasoned that HRA expense assessments created distinctive administrative inclinations in the faculty lay off choice setting. Gul (1984) endeavored to study the handiness of HR turnover cost data for work turnover choice making in an example of Australian Accounting Firms. Bayes (1984) led an experimental examination of the impacts of HRA data on choice making. Malik (1993) completed an experimental examination to know the effect of HRA data on choice making. Sen et.al (2008) in their study make a logical examination concerning whether HR data has any effect on inside choice making i.e. in the connection of staff administration choice making identified with worker enlistment and representative turnover control in keeping money industry of Bangladesh. There are such a large number of studies that bolster the theorized handiness of HRA during the time spent choice making by inner and outer clients. Muniramappa, C.M (1988), in his paper "Human Resource Accounting: Problems in Application and Adoption" tosses light on some theoretical issues in the method for HRA. Gupta D.K (1992) did an overview on "Plausible Problem Areas Confronting Human Resource Accounting". He with the assistance of poll tries to recognize the significant issues that restrain the development of HRA regardless of its utility. There has additionally been an expanding acknowledgment of the idea of HRA, as confirm by the stream of writing on different parts of HRA. Yet, there are not very many associations included in the methodical estimation and reporting of HRA data. Numerous organizations began the framework and quit reporting following couple of years. In spite of the fact that the clients of the data are intrigued and welcome HRA reporting however they neglect to toss light on the vacuum made by the resistance of the associations to embrace an arrangement of human asset bookkeeping. It is vital to know the impression of the administration concerning why the organizations are not approaching to receive the framework inspite of the utility of the framework to the administration for choice making. It is the administration to choose with respect to reception of arrangement of HRA and the structure in which it ought to be made accessible to the interior and outer clients. The proposed work is a stage forward in the course that on the off chance that it is so helpful what are the issue territories defying the development of the HRA.
Goals OF THE STUDY
Human Resource Accounting helps the administration in taking choices. Inspite of the employments of HRA not very many organizations are approaching to report HRA data in their yearly reports and numerous organizations both in India and abroad quit reporting this important data in their yearly reports. It was seen that potentially certain issues were connected with the outline and the utilization of HRA framework. Remembering this the present paper is arranged with the goal to have direct data of such issues from the chiefs who were particularly connected with the planning of such frameworks in chose Indian organizations.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
For the present study, beat one hundred organizations from open division with an equivalent number of associations from the private area (according to the Economic Times rating for 2007-08 on the premise of aggregate capital utilized) were chosen. These associations had been chosen on the supposition that human asset bookkeeping being a rising field in bookkeeping in India huge associations may present it in their yearly reports. The yearly reports of two hundred associations were gotten to from the sites of the separate organizations and the Stock Exchange. These reports were filtered to recognize the organizations reporting human asset bookkeeping. It was found that numerous associations included in their yearly reports some data about HR like expenses acquired on employing, preparing HR, representative remuneration and so forth. However just ten associations, seven in broad daylight part and four in the private segment, reported human asset bookkeeping in their yearly reports. To comprehend the view of directors in regards to the issue territories a poll was outlined and sent to twenty four associations that are in no time uncovering HRA data in their yearly reports and others that began HRA framework however had now ceased revelation in their yearly reports with a demand that just those administrators ought to react who have learning of the human asset bookkeeping framework and were connected with the planning of such a framework. The organizations that neglected to react to the sent poll were reached in individual to look for their reaction to the survey. Through mail and individual contact a sum of nineteen reactions could be gathered for investigation that worked out to be 79.16 percent of the 24 organizations chose for the study.
RESEARCH TECHNIQUE APPLIED
Likert Five-Point scale was applied in order to analyze the results. The percentage response for each category was calculated and the various weights assigned to different opinions as per Likert Five Point scale i.e. Strongly agree =5, Agree= 4, Neutral = 3, Disagree = 2, Strongly disagree = 1.The mean scores and standard deviation scores were calculated for the same. The result of the study is summarized in Table I.
PERCEPTION OF MANAGERS REGARDING PROBLEM AREAS
The results of manager�s perception regarding the problem areas in developing and instituting the HRA system are summarized in the following Table I.
Table I Perception of the Respondents to Various Problem Areas
Sl. No |
Response Questions |
5 |
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
Mean |
Standard Deviation |
Ranks |
1 |
It is the organizational system and not the individual human element that is the prime determinant of the value of human resources |
15.79% |
73.69% |
5.26% |
5.26% |
0.00% |
4.00 |
0.58 |
1 |
2 |
Lack of symmetry with traditional accounting procedures |
0.00% |
78.95% |
5.26% |
15.79% |
0.00% |
3.36 |
0.76 |
8 |
3 |
Lack of agreement concerning the procedure of accounting |
0.00% |
89.74% |
10.53% |
0.00% |
0.00% |
3.89 |
0.50 |
2 |
4 |
Difficulty in determining the norms for amortization |
0.00% |
73.69% |
21.05% |
5.26% |
0.00% |
3.68 |
0.58 |
6 |
5 |
Calculation of Discount Rate |
15.78% |
42.11% |
42.11% |
0.00% |
0.00% |
3.74 |
0.73 |
4 |
6 |
Non preparation of Employee Career Growth Plan |
10.53% |
42.10% |
47.37% |
0.00% |
0.00% |
3.63 |
0.68 |
7 |
7 |
Disastrous impact on the attitude of employees whose values are declining |
0.00% |
68.42% |
31.58% |
0.00% |
0.00% |
3.68 |
0.48 |
5 |
8 |
Unwillingness of the organizations to introduce system at huge cost |
21.05% |
47.37% |
31.58% |
0.00% |
0.00% |
3.89 |
0.54 |
3 |
Applied Problem
HRA has the ability to give the expense and the worth measures of workers relying upon the outline of the framework. On account of quality based estimation of HRA it is accepted that an individual or a gathering of people is the prime determinant of worth. The main inquiry tended to the directors was that it is the hierarchical framework and not the individual human component that is the prime determinant of the estimation of HR. HRA, as opposed to this, expected that it is the individual or a gathering of people that is the prime determinant of quality. To this announcement 89.48 percent of the respondents concurred (it incorporates 15.79% that firmly concurred), 5.26 percent stayed unbiased and same rate indicated contradiction. This applied issue scored mean 4.00 with the standard deviation 0.58.
Absence of Symmetry with conventional bookkeeping framework
The idea of imperviousness to change is additionally one of the issues. Customary bookkeeping framework that has been taken after from quite a while needs a few progressions if human asset bookkeeping is to be connected in the genuine sense. Therefore the customary bookkeeping framework needs adjustments as it neglects to acknowledge HR as resources.
The second question to the supervisors focuses on the issue that absence of symmetry of HRA with conventional bookkeeping methods hinders the development of the idea. To this view 78.95 percent of the respondents concurred with the issue and 15.79 percent oppose this idea. The
mean score against this was 3.63 with the standard deviation of 0.76.
Absence of assention concerning the methodology
Numerous associations who propose to present human asset bookkeeping think that it hard to touch base at a for the most part pleasant technique for valuation and reporting of HR. There is an expansive arrangement of expense and worth methodologies. All valuation routines are in view of specific suppositions that could conceivably be valid.
The third question was identified with the issue of understanding concerning the method of representing HR. Most of the respondents conceded to this issue i.e. 89.74 percent conceded to this issue while the others stayed unbiased. The mean score was 3.89 with the standard deviation 0.50.
Amortization Rate
According to the recorded expense approach for estimation of the HR amortization rate gives the figure of amortization. This sum must be charged to the benefit and misfortune account consistently. It is exceptionally hard to create fitting standards in such manner. It is ascribed to the trouble in deciding the standards for amortization under unique expense approach that antagonistically influences the development of HR bookkeeping. The fourth question was concerned with this issue. Of the aggregate respondents 73.69 percent concurred, 5.26 percent differ though others stayed impartial. The mean score was 3.68 with standard deviation of 0.73.
Figuring of Discount Rate
Another issue that has not been settled so far is about the figuring of the rebate rate in light of the fact that so as to locate the present estimation of future profit of a representative the income must be reduced at a specific markdown rate. Various alternatives are accessible to the associations for utilizing distinctive rebate rates. In light of the fifth question that focuses on figuring of markdown rate, 42.11 percent of the respondents stayed unbiased though all the others concurred that estimation of rebate rate was likewise one of the issues.
Vocation arrangement
The development of human asset bookkeeping has been antagonistically influenced because of the non-planning of the worker's profession development anticipate which the worth based models depend. It is hard to make a representative's vocation arrangement. Around 63 percent of the respondents concurred while 37 percent stayed nonpartisan. The mean score was 3.63 percent with the standard deviation of 0.68.
Behavioral part of HR
Another issue identified with the utilization of human asset bookkeeping is concerned with the behavioral part of HR. It is conceivable that worries with respect to the impact of the HRA on human conduct may have constrained the associations to be hesitant to utilize this framework. The HRA data may have a grievous effect on the mentality of representatives whose qualities are declining. Question seven looks for the impression of directors with respect to conduct sway. Of the aggregate respondents 47.37 percent stayed impartial though the staying communicated their assention.
Expense included in outlining the framework
Certain fundamental prerequisites are essential for the reception of human asset bookkeeping. Notwithstanding the limit of the association to plan a suitable framework and proceed with it more than a drawn out stretch of time sufficiently adequate to bring the craved results is additionally critical. The expense included in outlining a framework and its reception is a noteworthy restricting consider an endeavor to present HRA in modern circumstance in India. The unwillingness of the association to present the framework at a gigantic expense has unfavorably influenced the development of HRA. 68.42 percent of the respondents concurred with this while others stayed nonpartisan. The mean score was 3.89 with standard deviation of 0.54.
Different issues
None of the respondents gave their feeling to some other issue related with the use of human asset bookkeeping.
CONCLUSION
On the premise of the mean score and standard deviation earned by every announcement we can infer that the administrators connected with the outline of the arrangement of human asset bookkeeping feel that the reasonable issues is the most imperative issue territory. The powerlessness of the joining of human asset bookkeeping framework with the customary bookkeeping is additionally one of the significant issues as it picked up the second most astounding mean score. The eighth inquiry concerned with unwillingness of the associations to present the framework at a gigantic expense picked up the third rank. This issue emerges in light of the fact that it is not mandatory to unveil the HRA data and associations take their own particular freedom. They would prefer not to present the framework as it includes tremendous expense.
The minimum weightage was allocated to the issue of absence of symmetry with conventional bookkeeping techniques. Count of the rebate rate is likewise one of the issues and it was positioned at fourth position according to its mean score and standard deviation.
At long last we can reason that the view of the administrators gives distinctive weightage to diverse parts of the employments of human asset bookkeeping and their issue zones. With the time and improvement of the human asset bookkeeping idea, the weightage appointed to a few viewpoints vary according to the overview directed by Dinesh Gupta. To discover an answer for the issue the analysts ought to approach and concentrate on the different particular issue zones in light of positioning and ought to give a doable answer for the same to make the idea generally worthy and practicable on the grounds that HRA data is exceptionally helpful in administrative choice making.
REFERENCES
I. Bayes, Paul Eugene. (1984): An Empirical Investigation of the Effects of Human Resource Accounting Information on Decision-Making: Results of Mail Survey, Thesis, University of Kentucky, U.S.A.
II. Brummet, R.L., Flamholtz, E.G., Pyle, W.C. (1969), �Human Resource Accounting: A Tool to Increase Managerial Effectiveness�, Management Accounting, p.p.12-15.
III. Flamholtz, Eric. G. (1971), �Should Your Organization Attempt to Value its Human resources?� California Management Review, Winter, pp. 40-45.
IV. Flamholtz, Eric. G. (1979), �Human Resource Accounting: State of the Art and Future Prospects�, Annual Accounting Review, Vol. 1, p. 219.
V. Framholtz, Eric. G. (1999), �Human Resource Accounting: Advances in Concepts, Methods & Applications�, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Third Edition, p.12.
VI. Gul, Ferdinand A. (1984), �An Empirical Study of the Usefulness of Human Resources Turnover Cost in Australian Accounting Firm�, Accounting, Organization and Society, Vol. 9, pp. 233-239.
VII. Gupta, D.K. (1990), �Human Resource Accounting In India: A Perspective�, ASCI Journal of Management, Vol.20, No.3, September, pp-1-9.
VIII. Gupta, D.K. (1992), �Probable Problem Areas Confronting Human Resource Accounting: A Survey� Journal of Accounting and Finance, Vol. VI, No. 1, spring, pp71-78.
IX. Levine, Marc. (1980),�Perspective in Accounting for Human Resources�, The Chartered Accountant, October, pp. 295-97.
X. Malik, R.K. (1993), �Human Resource Accounting and Decision-Making�, Anmol Publishers, New Delhi.
XI. Muniramappa, C.M., �Human Resource Accounting: Problems in Application and Adoption� Accounting for Human Assets, 1988, pp 260-65.
XII. Prabhakar Rao D., �Human Resource Accounting� Inter- India Publications, New Delhi, 1986, Reeta, Upasna, �Managerial Uses of HRA: A Survey�, IJRCM, Vol. 3 No.9, September 2012, pp. 77-79.
XIII. Sen, D.K., Jain, S.C., Jat, S.L and Saha, R.K. (2008), �Human Resource Accounting Information: It�s Impact on Internal Decision-Making�, The Journal of Accounting and Finance, Vol. XXII, No. 1, Oct-March, pp. 23-56.
XIV. Tomassini, Lawrence A. (1977), �Assessing the Impact of Human Resource Accounting: An Experimental Study of Managerial Decision Preferences�, The Accounting Review, Vol. 52, No. 4, October, pp. 904-914.
